570
MYELOID CELL DYSREGULATION ASSOCIATES WITH NON-RESPONSE TO ANTI-TNF THERAPIES.
Date
May 7, 2023
Explore related products in the following collection:
Society: AGA
Background:
The pathogenesis of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) involves crosstalk between genetic and microbial factors that influence immune reactions. Tofacitinib, a pan JAK-STAT inhibitor, is a small molecule indicated for the treatment of moderate-to-severe ulcerative colitis (UC). However, approximately 30-40% of patients will not response to tofacitinib, and underscores the importance of identifying individuals who may respond to drug prior to therapy initiation. We utilized patient-derived intestinal organoids to predict responsiveness to tofacitinib.
Methods:
We cultured colonic organoids derived from endoscopic mucosal pinch biopsies from 4 healthy donors (HD) and 24 patients with UC initiating tofacitinib at weeks 0 and 24. Mechanically disrupted organoids were dissociated into 96-well tissue culture plate. The organoids were cultured in differentiation media (IF media) supplemented with Y-27632 for the first 2 days, and then stimulated with 20 ng/ml of human(h) TNFα and 1,000 IU/ml of hIFNβ or 20 ng/ml of hTNFα and hIFNγ in the presence of DMSO, 1, or 10 μM of tofacitinib for 5 days. Percent viable organoids was determined by daily quantification of the number of intact organoids. Change in total Mayo scores at weeks 0 and 24 were correlated with organoid viability.
Results:
Tofacitinib at 1 and 10 μM significantly rescued the decreased viability of organoids-derived from both HD and UC patients under hTNFα+hIFNβ or hTNFα+hIFNγ stimulation, consistent with tofacitinib sensitivity (Figure 1A). UC patient-derived organoids showed heterogenous viability when treated with 1 μM tofacitinib (Figure 1A). 10 UC organoid lines were sensitive to tofacitinib (UC-S) and phenocopied HD-derived organoids. 14 UC organoid lines displayed comparable viability under hTNFα+hIFNγ stimulation despite 1μM of tofacitinib, consistent with tofacitinib tolerance (UC-T1 and 2; Figure 1B). 7 organoid lines (UC-T2) demonstrated impaired viability rescue under both cytokine combinations with tofacitinib (Figure 1B). Total Mayo scores of patients corresponding to UC-S were significantly decreased after tofacitinib treatment (Figure 1C). Total Mayo scores were unchanged in the patients corresponding to UC-T1 and T2 (Figure 1C).
Conclusion:
Our findings indicate that patient-derived intestinal organoids display heterogeneous sensitivity to tofacitinib. The ability of tofacitinib to rescue organoid viability directly correlated with change in the total Mayo score, suggesting that organoids are a useful platform to predict drug responsiveness of individual patients.
The pathogenesis of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) involves crosstalk between genetic and microbial factors that influence immune reactions. Tofacitinib, a pan JAK-STAT inhibitor, is a small molecule indicated for the treatment of moderate-to-severe ulcerative colitis (UC). However, approximately 30-40% of patients will not response to tofacitinib, and underscores the importance of identifying individuals who may respond to drug prior to therapy initiation. We utilized patient-derived intestinal organoids to predict responsiveness to tofacitinib.
Methods:
We cultured colonic organoids derived from endoscopic mucosal pinch biopsies from 4 healthy donors (HD) and 24 patients with UC initiating tofacitinib at weeks 0 and 24. Mechanically disrupted organoids were dissociated into 96-well tissue culture plate. The organoids were cultured in differentiation media (IF media) supplemented with Y-27632 for the first 2 days, and then stimulated with 20 ng/ml of human(h) TNFα and 1,000 IU/ml of hIFNβ or 20 ng/ml of hTNFα and hIFNγ in the presence of DMSO, 1, or 10 μM of tofacitinib for 5 days. Percent viable organoids was determined by daily quantification of the number of intact organoids. Change in total Mayo scores at weeks 0 and 24 were correlated with organoid viability.
Results:
Tofacitinib at 1 and 10 μM significantly rescued the decreased viability of organoids-derived from both HD and UC patients under hTNFα+hIFNβ or hTNFα+hIFNγ stimulation, consistent with tofacitinib sensitivity (Figure 1A). UC patient-derived organoids showed heterogenous viability when treated with 1 μM tofacitinib (Figure 1A). 10 UC organoid lines were sensitive to tofacitinib (UC-S) and phenocopied HD-derived organoids. 14 UC organoid lines displayed comparable viability under hTNFα+hIFNγ stimulation despite 1μM of tofacitinib, consistent with tofacitinib tolerance (UC-T1 and 2; Figure 1B). 7 organoid lines (UC-T2) demonstrated impaired viability rescue under both cytokine combinations with tofacitinib (Figure 1B). Total Mayo scores of patients corresponding to UC-S were significantly decreased after tofacitinib treatment (Figure 1C). Total Mayo scores were unchanged in the patients corresponding to UC-T1 and T2 (Figure 1C).
Conclusion:
Our findings indicate that patient-derived intestinal organoids display heterogeneous sensitivity to tofacitinib. The ability of tofacitinib to rescue organoid viability directly correlated with change in the total Mayo score, suggesting that organoids are a useful platform to predict drug responsiveness of individual patients.
Background:
While biological treatment has proven effective in treating Crohn’s disease (CD), we still face an important therapeutic ceiling, as a large proportion of patients fail to demonstrate primary response or lose response over time. Therefore, pre-treatment selection of patients with increased potential to objectively respond is of paramount importance, yet biomarkers facilitating such selection are lacking. Previous epigenome-wide association studies associated differential DNA methylation with CD-specific phenotypes, of which the majority suggests a potential use in classification and prediction of response to treatment.
Methods:
We therefore prospectively measured peripheral blood DNA methylation signatures of 184 adult CD patients before (T1) and after a median of 28 weeks (T2) of treatment with adalimumab (ADA), vedolizumab (VEDO) or ustekinumab (USTE) in a discovery (n=88) and independently collected internal validation cohort (n=96) using the Illumina EPIC BeadChip array. Response (R) was defined as the combination of endoscopic response (≥50% reduction in SES-CD score) and steroid-free clinical response (≥3 point drop in HBI or HBI ≤4 AND no systemic steroids) and/or biochemical response (≥50% reduction in C-reactive protein (CRP) and fecal calprotectin or a CRP ≤5 g/mL and fecal calprotectin ≤250 µg/g). Samples taken at T1 were used for biomarker identification and classification through stability selected gradient boosting, while samples taken at T2 as well as publicly available intraclass correlation (ICC) data were used to evaluate the long-term stability of our identified CpG markers.
Results:
A total of 58 ADA-patients (NR=29, NNR=29), 64 VEDO-patients (NR=36, NNR=28) and 62 USTE-patients (NR=30, NNR=32) were included (table 1). Classification analyses at T1 selected distinct CpG-signatures that, in combination, predict clinical- and endoscopic response to ADA (100 loci), VEDO (22 loci) and USTE (68 loci) with high performance (AUC ADA=0.73, VEDO=0.89 and USTE=0.94) upon validation. In addition, these signatures did not significantly differ between T1 and T2 and the majority demonstrated ICC-values ≥0.90, indicating long-term hyper stability irrespective of inflammatory status or external exposure. Furthermore, genes annotated to the CpGs of interest suggest drug specific involvement in TNF-signaling, endothelial cell-cell adhesion, integrin dependent T-cell homing, the innate immune system and Th17/Treg differentiation, corroborating to the mode of action of each drug.
Conclusion: Here, we report on 3 novel validated signatures of highly stable CpG-loci that predict endoscopic- and clinical response in CD patients treated with ADA, VEDO or USTE. Additional external- and clinical validation as part of EPIC-CD and the OMICROHN clinical trial are currently ongoing.
While biological treatment has proven effective in treating Crohn’s disease (CD), we still face an important therapeutic ceiling, as a large proportion of patients fail to demonstrate primary response or lose response over time. Therefore, pre-treatment selection of patients with increased potential to objectively respond is of paramount importance, yet biomarkers facilitating such selection are lacking. Previous epigenome-wide association studies associated differential DNA methylation with CD-specific phenotypes, of which the majority suggests a potential use in classification and prediction of response to treatment.
Methods:
We therefore prospectively measured peripheral blood DNA methylation signatures of 184 adult CD patients before (T1) and after a median of 28 weeks (T2) of treatment with adalimumab (ADA), vedolizumab (VEDO) or ustekinumab (USTE) in a discovery (n=88) and independently collected internal validation cohort (n=96) using the Illumina EPIC BeadChip array. Response (R) was defined as the combination of endoscopic response (≥50% reduction in SES-CD score) and steroid-free clinical response (≥3 point drop in HBI or HBI ≤4 AND no systemic steroids) and/or biochemical response (≥50% reduction in C-reactive protein (CRP) and fecal calprotectin or a CRP ≤5 g/mL and fecal calprotectin ≤250 µg/g). Samples taken at T1 were used for biomarker identification and classification through stability selected gradient boosting, while samples taken at T2 as well as publicly available intraclass correlation (ICC) data were used to evaluate the long-term stability of our identified CpG markers.
Results:
A total of 58 ADA-patients (NR=29, NNR=29), 64 VEDO-patients (NR=36, NNR=28) and 62 USTE-patients (NR=30, NNR=32) were included (table 1). Classification analyses at T1 selected distinct CpG-signatures that, in combination, predict clinical- and endoscopic response to ADA (100 loci), VEDO (22 loci) and USTE (68 loci) with high performance (AUC ADA=0.73, VEDO=0.89 and USTE=0.94) upon validation. In addition, these signatures did not significantly differ between T1 and T2 and the majority demonstrated ICC-values ≥0.90, indicating long-term hyper stability irrespective of inflammatory status or external exposure. Furthermore, genes annotated to the CpGs of interest suggest drug specific involvement in TNF-signaling, endothelial cell-cell adhesion, integrin dependent T-cell homing, the innate immune system and Th17/Treg differentiation, corroborating to the mode of action of each drug.
Conclusion: Here, we report on 3 novel validated signatures of highly stable CpG-loci that predict endoscopic- and clinical response in CD patients treated with ADA, VEDO or USTE. Additional external- and clinical validation as part of EPIC-CD and the OMICROHN clinical trial are currently ongoing.
Figure 1. Machine learning methodology, model performance and radar plots.
Table 1. Baseline characteristics
Background: Mirikizumab (miri), a p19-directed IL-23 antibody, showed efficacy in ulcerative colitis (UC)1. Miri modulates transcripts associated with disease activity and anti-TNF resistance in UC and increases expression of transcripts associated with healthy mucosa2. Here, we evaluate the transcription profile of patients with UC who respond to placebo (PBO, 20.6%) or miri 200mg treatment (59.7%) versus non-responders and build a model that can predict response in patients with UC.
Methods: In the phase 2 AMAC trial (NCT02589665), patients were randomized 1:1:1:1 to receive intravenous PBO (N=63), 50mg miri (N=63), or 200mg miri (n=62) with possible exposure-based dose increases or fixed 600mg miri (n=61) at Week (W)0, 4 and 8. Colonic biopsies were collected at baseline, W12, and W52. An Affymetrix HTA2.0 microarray measured gene expression. Limma comparing values at baseline and W12 determined differentially expressed genes (DEGs). DEGs maintaining their W12 expression level through W52 among responders in either the PBO and miri 200mg arms were designated as similarly expressed genes (DEGSEGs).
XGBoost models3 were trained to predict clinical response (decrease in 9-point Mayo subscore [rectal bleeding, stool frequency, endoscopy] of ≥2 points and ≥35% from baseline [BL] with either a decrease of RB subscore of ≥1 or an RB subscore of 0 or 1) using baseline levels of DEGSEGs and TNF biomarkers. Leave-one-out cross validation of the models using AMAC data and validation experiments by training on the PROTECT data4 then predicting in AMAC were used to evaluate our models.
Results: Miri 200mg responders were associated with 84 DEGSEGs, PBO responders were associated with 26 DEGSEGs, and 21 DEGSEGs were common to both. When using the PROTECT data as the training data and AMAC data as the validation cohort (Figure A), we were able to achieve high ROC-AUC and PR-AUCs using the top 36 (FC > 1.5) miri DEGSEGs (PR-AUC=0.78), TNF biomarkers (PR-AUC=0.91), or combined (PR-AUC=0.93) gene sets as the features (Figure B-E) and found that the response prediction was significantly higher in AMAC responders vs. non-responders (Figure F).
Conclusions: Baseline transcript features were predictive of clinical response in patients with UC treated with miri 200mg and our model distinguished responders from non-responders. Future studies may further validate this model.
References:
1Sandborn WJ, et al. Gastroenterology. 2020;158(3):537-549.e10.
2Steere B, et al. J Crohns Colitis. 2020;S103-S104.
3Chen T, et al. Proceedings of the 22nd ACM SIGKDD International Conference. 2016;7285-794.
4Hyams JS, et al. Lancet Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2017;2(12):855-868.
Methods: In the phase 2 AMAC trial (NCT02589665), patients were randomized 1:1:1:1 to receive intravenous PBO (N=63), 50mg miri (N=63), or 200mg miri (n=62) with possible exposure-based dose increases or fixed 600mg miri (n=61) at Week (W)0, 4 and 8. Colonic biopsies were collected at baseline, W12, and W52. An Affymetrix HTA2.0 microarray measured gene expression. Limma comparing values at baseline and W12 determined differentially expressed genes (DEGs). DEGs maintaining their W12 expression level through W52 among responders in either the PBO and miri 200mg arms were designated as similarly expressed genes (DEGSEGs).
XGBoost models3 were trained to predict clinical response (decrease in 9-point Mayo subscore [rectal bleeding, stool frequency, endoscopy] of ≥2 points and ≥35% from baseline [BL] with either a decrease of RB subscore of ≥1 or an RB subscore of 0 or 1) using baseline levels of DEGSEGs and TNF biomarkers. Leave-one-out cross validation of the models using AMAC data and validation experiments by training on the PROTECT data4 then predicting in AMAC were used to evaluate our models.
Results: Miri 200mg responders were associated with 84 DEGSEGs, PBO responders were associated with 26 DEGSEGs, and 21 DEGSEGs were common to both. When using the PROTECT data as the training data and AMAC data as the validation cohort (Figure A), we were able to achieve high ROC-AUC and PR-AUCs using the top 36 (FC > 1.5) miri DEGSEGs (PR-AUC=0.78), TNF biomarkers (PR-AUC=0.91), or combined (PR-AUC=0.93) gene sets as the features (Figure B-E) and found that the response prediction was significantly higher in AMAC responders vs. non-responders (Figure F).
Conclusions: Baseline transcript features were predictive of clinical response in patients with UC treated with miri 200mg and our model distinguished responders from non-responders. Future studies may further validate this model.
References:
1Sandborn WJ, et al. Gastroenterology. 2020;158(3):537-549.e10.
2Steere B, et al. J Crohns Colitis. 2020;S103-S104.
3Chen T, et al. Proceedings of the 22nd ACM SIGKDD International Conference. 2016;7285-794.
4Hyams JS, et al. Lancet Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2017;2(12):855-868.
Figure 1. Predictive accuracy of models predicting treatment response in AMAC patients after being trained on the PROTECT cohort (A), Miri stringent DEGSEGs (B), and TNF-associated genes (C). The union of both gene sets (D-E) are predictive of response. Responders had higher predicted values for response than non-responders (F).
Background
While most of the Ulcerative Colitis (UC)-related mucosal studies have focused on whole intestinal tissues or lamina propria (LP) alone, epithelial compartment (EC)-specific studies are largely lacking. Here, we have defined EC-associated molecular and cellular dynamics during active UC and studied their association with response to Tumor Necrosis Factor inhibitor (TNFi) therapy.
Method
EC-focused analyses encompassing total RNA sequencing (RNA sequencing), single-cell (sc-)RNA sequencing, spatial transcriptomics (ST), microscopy and flow cytometry (FC) were performed in a cohort of UC patients (n=103) and healthy controls (HC, n=116); Primary Cohort (PC). Inflammation-associated signatures were validated in an internal validation cohort (VC-1; UC, n= 401; HC, n = 243). Additionally, 3 distinct validation cohorts (VC-2a, n=23; VC-3b, n=48; VC-4c, n=214) were used to determine cellular and molecular phenotypes that were associated with TNFi-treatment response.
a. Gut, 2018; PMID-27802155
b. Am J Gastroenterol., 2011; PMID- 21448149
c. Lancet Gastroenterol Hepatol., 2022; PMID: 34798036
Results
Total RNA and scRNA sequencing analyses along with FC revealed distinct immune perturbations in the EC of patients with UC, including a major increase in neutrophils, monocyte-macrophages (MoMac) and inflammatory macrophages, while EC-resident, homeostatic gd T cells were significantly reduced (FIG. 1A, B). ST identified significantly reduced frequencies of mature epithelial subtypes in UC and significantly increased co-localization between multiple cell types, prominently between epithelial cells and myeloid cells (FIG. 1C), that was confirmed by microscopy (FIG. 1D).
A signature of 255 EC specific inflammation-associated genes was derived that reversed with TNFi. This included treatment associated reduced expression of genes such as CSF3R, FCGR3B, MZB1, PDPN, TREM1, FPR2 with a concomitant increased expression of genes like BEST4, CA2, SLC16A1, UGT1A10 (FIG. 1E). Interrogation of UC-associated inflammatory cell types within VC-2, VC-3, and VC-4 demonstrated that reduction in neutrophils, MoMac, macrophages, DCs and plasma cells and an increase in epithelial cells was associated with TNFi response. Furthermore, early (W8-W10) reductions in myeloid cell- and plasma cell-associated genes was associated with TNFi response (FIG. 1F, G).
Conclusions
Detailed multiomic characterization of the EC reveals myeloid cell-, plasma cell- and epithelial cell-associated cell types that are associated with non-response to TNFi and can help define strategies for rational drug sequencing and combinations in UC.
While most of the Ulcerative Colitis (UC)-related mucosal studies have focused on whole intestinal tissues or lamina propria (LP) alone, epithelial compartment (EC)-specific studies are largely lacking. Here, we have defined EC-associated molecular and cellular dynamics during active UC and studied their association with response to Tumor Necrosis Factor inhibitor (TNFi) therapy.
Method
EC-focused analyses encompassing total RNA sequencing (RNA sequencing), single-cell (sc-)RNA sequencing, spatial transcriptomics (ST), microscopy and flow cytometry (FC) were performed in a cohort of UC patients (n=103) and healthy controls (HC, n=116); Primary Cohort (PC). Inflammation-associated signatures were validated in an internal validation cohort (VC-1; UC, n= 401; HC, n = 243). Additionally, 3 distinct validation cohorts (VC-2a, n=23; VC-3b, n=48; VC-4c, n=214) were used to determine cellular and molecular phenotypes that were associated with TNFi-treatment response.
a. Gut, 2018; PMID-27802155
b. Am J Gastroenterol., 2011; PMID- 21448149
c. Lancet Gastroenterol Hepatol., 2022; PMID: 34798036
Results
Total RNA and scRNA sequencing analyses along with FC revealed distinct immune perturbations in the EC of patients with UC, including a major increase in neutrophils, monocyte-macrophages (MoMac) and inflammatory macrophages, while EC-resident, homeostatic gd T cells were significantly reduced (FIG. 1A, B). ST identified significantly reduced frequencies of mature epithelial subtypes in UC and significantly increased co-localization between multiple cell types, prominently between epithelial cells and myeloid cells (FIG. 1C), that was confirmed by microscopy (FIG. 1D).
A signature of 255 EC specific inflammation-associated genes was derived that reversed with TNFi. This included treatment associated reduced expression of genes such as CSF3R, FCGR3B, MZB1, PDPN, TREM1, FPR2 with a concomitant increased expression of genes like BEST4, CA2, SLC16A1, UGT1A10 (FIG. 1E). Interrogation of UC-associated inflammatory cell types within VC-2, VC-3, and VC-4 demonstrated that reduction in neutrophils, MoMac, macrophages, DCs and plasma cells and an increase in epithelial cells was associated with TNFi response. Furthermore, early (W8-W10) reductions in myeloid cell- and plasma cell-associated genes was associated with TNFi response (FIG. 1F, G).
Conclusions
Detailed multiomic characterization of the EC reveals myeloid cell-, plasma cell- and epithelial cell-associated cell types that are associated with non-response to TNFi and can help define strategies for rational drug sequencing and combinations in UC.
Presenter
Speakers
Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
Tracks
Related Products
SUBCUTANEOUS INFLIXIMAB (CT-P13) AS MAINTENANCE THERAPY FOR CROHN'S DISEASE: A PHASE 3, RANDOMIZED, PLACEBO-CONTROLLED STUDY (LIBERTY-CD).
BACKGROUND: After successful induction, a subset of patients with Crohn’s disease (CD) experience a secondary loss of response (LoR) to ustekinumab (UST) maintenance therapy. Dose intensification may assist in regaining response…
ANTI-GRANULOCYTE MACROPHAGE-COLONY STIMULATING FACTOR AUTOANTIBODIES ARE ASSOCIATED WITH DEVELOPMENT OF COMPLICATIONS IN RECENTLY DIAGNOSED CROHN’S DISEASE PATIENTS
BACKGROUND: Anti-granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor autoantibodies (anti-GM-CSF) have been associated with development of Crohn’s disease (CD) and complications at time of diagnosis. There are limited data on anti-GM-CSF as a prognostic biomarker in CD…
EFFICACY AND SAFETY OF UPADACITINIB FOR THE TREATMENT OF FISTULAS AND FISSURES IN PATIENTS WITH CROHN’S DISEASE
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: A treat-to-target (TTT) strategy of striving for symptomatic and endoscopic remission is recommended for the management of inflammatory bowel diseases (IBD). Yet, real-world uptake of TTT strategies has been modest…
AGA Patricia and Ralph Giannella Lecture: Road to Prediction: Inflammatory Bowel Disease Risk and Outcomes
The burden of IBD is rising globally. This session aims to understand the role of genetics in the development of IBD in diverse populations and define the pre-disease state in IBD. It will also explore the emerging field of multi-omics to clinically characterize IBD…
